コ

コステロの

Costello’s New York City Visiting Hours Tickets and Travel Guide

Date: 2025/06/15

Introduction

New York City’s literary and artistic heritage comes alive when you explore the legacy of Costello’s, a legendary Midtown Manhattan bar that served as a creative haven for writers, cartoonists, and journalists. Although the original Costello’s closed its doors in the early 1990s, its spirit lives on at the Overlook Lounge, located at 225 East 44th Street. This guide offers a comprehensive look at Costello’s history, cultural significance, visiting information, accessibility, travel tips, and nearby attractions, designed to enhance your NYC experience.

Introduction
Costello’s New York City Visiting Hours Tickets and Travel Guide

Historical Overview of Costello’s

Founding and Early Years (1929–1950s)

Costello’s, also affectionately known as Tim’s, was established in 1929 by Irish immigrant brothers Tim and Joe Costello during the Prohibition era. Originally a speakeasy located near Third Avenue and East 44th Street, it operated under the shadow of the Third Avenue El. Tim Costello, distinguished by his welcoming demeanor and literary interests, quickly integrated into New York’s social and literary circles. After the repeal of Prohibition in 1933, Costello’s relocated to 701 Third Avenue, where it cultivated a reputation as an inclusive venue, drawing both blue-collar workers and prominent figures from the literary and journalistic worlds, including contributors to The New Yorker and the New York Daily News.

Literary and Artistic Significance

Costello’s rose to fame as a treasured haunt for New York’s literary elite, hosting luminaries such as Ernest Hemingway, John Steinbeck, James Thurber, Maeve Brennan, and Brendan Behan. Its artistic legacy is notably marked by its iconic murals. The bar initially featured a “Battle of the Sexes” mural by James Thurber in the mid-1930s. Though this original was lost, a new mural, created in 1976 by a collective of renowned cartoonists including Bill Gallo and Al Jaffee, continues to grace the walls and celebrates Costello’s artistic heritage.

Mythology and Cultural Impact

Immortalized in John McNulty’s New Yorker stories, Costello’s transcended its identity as mere bar to become a vibrant hub of creativity and social inclusivity. It symbolized the camaraderie and democratic spirit prevalent in mid-20th-century Manhattan, fostering lively discussions among artists, writers, and ordinary New Yorkers.

Relocations and Closure

Following an eviction from its Third Avenue location in 1973 due to building demolition, Costello’s reopened at 225 East 44th Street in 1974. The bar ultimately ceased operations in 1992, influenced by economic shifts and neighborhood changes. The space has since been occupied by the Overlook Lounge, which has preserved the 1976 cartoon mural and maintained the distinctive ambiance of Costello’s.

Visiting Costello’s Today: The Overlook Lounge

Location and Hours

Address: 225 East 44th Street (between 2nd and 3rd Avenues), Midtown Manhattan, New York, NY

Visiting Hours:

Monday to Friday: 4:00 PM – 12:00 AM
Saturday & Sunday: Closed

Please note: Hours are subject to change. It is advisable to check the Overlook Lounge’s official website or call ahead for the most current information.

Tickets and Admission

Entry to the Overlook Lounge is free. As a functioning bar, patrons are encouraged to purchase food or drinks to enjoy the venue.

Accessibility

The Overlook Lounge offers full wheelchair accessibility, including restrooms. Visitors requiring specific accommodations are encouraged to contact the lounge in advance.

How to Get There

Subway: Take the 4, 5, 6, 7, or S trains to Grand Central–42nd Street station, followed by a brief 5-minute walk eastward.
Bus: Numerous bus lines, including the M15 and M42, have stops in the vicinity.
Taxi/Rideshare: The location is easily accessible via taxi or rideshare services from anywhere in Midtown.

What to See and Do

Cartoon Mural: Admire the original 1976 mural, a collaboration by celebrated cartoonists, honoring Costello’s creative legacy.
Ambiance: Experience the bar’s atmosphere, which evokes Costello’s literary and artistic heritage. Staff can often share historical anecdotes.
Menu: Enjoy classic American pub fare alongside a selection of beers and cocktails, with affordable happy hour specials available.

Nearby Attractions

Within a 10-minute walk from the Overlook Lounge, you can explore:

Grand Central Terminal: An architectural marvel and major transportation hub.
Bryant Park: A lively urban green space offering various events and amenities.
New York Public Library: An iconic Beaux-Arts building housing significant historical collections.
Chrysler Building: A renowned Art Deco skyscraper.
Fifth Avenue: Famous for its high-end shopping and vibrant street life.

Travel Tips for Visitors

Optimal Visiting Time: Weekday afternoons or early evenings provide a more tranquil setting for appreciating the mural.
Reservations: While not necessary for small groups, reservations are recommended for larger parties or during peak times.
Dress Code: Casual dress is appropriate, aligning with the bar’s inclusive spirit.
Photography: Photography is permitted; however, be mindful of other patrons and staff.
Further Exploration: Consider a Midtown Manhattan walking tour to enhance your cultural and historical understanding of the area.
Accessibility: The venue is wheelchair accessible, ensuring ease of access to the bar and restrooms.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Q: Can I visit the original Costello’s bar? A: The original Costello’s bar is closed, but its legacy and iconic mural are preserved at the Overlook Lounge, located at 225 East 44th Street.

Q: Do I need tickets or reservations to visit? A: No tickets are required for entry. Reservations are recommended primarily for large groups or scheduled events.

Q: Is the mural accessible for wheelchair users? A: Yes, the Overlook Lounge is at street level and is fully wheelchair accessible.

Q: Are guided tours available at the site? A: While there are no official tours within the lounge, some Midtown historical walking tours incorporate visits to this significant location.

Q: What is the recommended attire for visiting? A: Casual attire is perfectly acceptable, reflecting the bar’s welcoming and relaxed atmosphere.

Conclusion

Costello’s enduring legacy as a central hub for New York’s creative community continues at the Overlook Lounge. This historic site offers an invaluable connection to the city’s literary and artistic past through its preserved mural and welcoming ambiance, standing as a testament to its cultural importance. Whether you are a history enthusiast, an art admirer, or simply seeking an authentic NYC bar experience, a visit to the Overlook Lounge is highly recommended. Enhance your trip by exploring the nearby Midtown landmarks and immersing yourself in the dynamic culture that defines New York City.

Visuals and Media Suggestions

High-quality images are recommended, with descriptive alt text:
- “1976 Costello’s cartoon mural at Overlook Lounge, Midtown Manhattan”
- “Exterior of Overlook Lounge at 225 East 44th Street, New York City”
- “Map of Midtown Manhattan highlighting Costello’s historic location and nearby literary sites”
Consider incorporating virtual tours or video content featuring historians discussing Costello’s cultural impact.

Embrace Costello’s enduring spirit by visiting the Overlook Lounge, and let the story of this legendary bar inspire your exploration of New York City’s literary and artistic heritage. For more cultural insights and travel updates, follow us on social media, explore related articles, and download the Audiala app for curated city guides and audio tours.